900 Locust St. Pittsburgh, PA 15282

ledewitz@duq.edu

The Case for Abolishing the Filibuster

By Bruce Ledewitz

My column on 11/13/2026 in Trib/Live

Trib Live

Featured Commentary

Bruce Ledewitz: The case for abolishing the filibuster

The Rotunda of the U.S. Capitol Building on Oct. 14, 2025, in Washington, D.C. (Andrew Harnik | Getty Images | TNS)

I keep hearing that the midterm results show the American people want change. Well, they are not likely to get it. The reason is not President Trump’s veto. The reason is the filibuster.

Democrats and Republicans have been abusing the filibuster for years. It used to be that the filibuster, which now allows a minority to require 60 votes in the Senate to pass legislation, was used sparingly. So, Congress was not paralyzed.

But in the last 20 years, our political parties have been using the filibuster to block even ordinary legislation favored by the other side. The filibuster is why nothing seems to change. The filibuster is why presidents and courts make all the important decisions. Our system was designed so that Congress controls policy through legislation. Legislation should only require 51 votes in the Senate to pass. Congress cannot function if almost every bill requires 60 votes to pass in the Senate. Neither party is likely to have that many votes.

The filibuster has been restricted in recent years so that it no longer applies to judicial and other nominations, or taxing and spending. That means that 51 votes are enough to confirm judges, cut taxes and increase spending. But not much else. This is the worst of all worlds.

People like me have been calling for an end to the filibuster for years, through Republican majorities and now a Democratic one. It’s not a matter of which party is in power. Let the people decide whether they like what each party does while in the majority. We just saw in the midterms that the people know how to reverse policies they don’t want.

Don’t worry about bad laws being passed if the filibuster is abolished. Bad laws are the price of democracy. It’s the only way that you can have a system of government that actually responds to the wishes of the people. If people vote for change and nothing changes, they will eventually decide that there is no reason to vote at all and that we need something other than democracy.

Yes, without the filibuster, Republicans might have passed nationwide voter ID. So what? Polls show Americans support that. And Democrats just won in states that require voter ID.

Yes, without the filibuster, Democrats might try to make Puerto Rico a state. But that would not be easy to do. It’s not clear that the people of Puerto Rico want statehood. Opinion there is divided. And would doing it help Democrats nationally if the American people did not like it?

There is a remedy for really bad laws. Such laws may well be unconstitutional. The courts are there to protect us, filibuster or no. I doubt that D.C. can be made a state, for example.

And don’t worry about the end of bipartisanship. First of all, we don’t have any real bipartisanship now. Second, the government is often mixed, as it will be in January with the Democrats controlling Congress and President Trump in the White House. Plus, there is not usually unanimity within each party. Often it is necessary to reach out to the other side to put together a majority for a bill.

One day soon, Democrats are going to propose an ordinary piece of legislation — raising the federal minimum wage, let’s say. Republicans in the Senate are going to respond with an unjustified filibuster. At that point, Democrats should finally get rid of the filibuster altogether.

The people want change. In the midterms, they voted for change. Let Congress respond. Democrats, abolish the filibuster.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Religious Rights Run Amok

Religious Rights Run Amok

My column today, Oct. 26, 2026, at OnlySky. I think of myself as a pro-religion secularist. Although I'm a nonbeliever, I strongly support the rights of people to their religious expressions without government interference. But even I must admit that America's...

Getting Old and Dying, Secular Style

Getting Old and Dying, Secular Style

Death is a hard reality for secularists, but also a reminder to find meaning in life where we can. Young people feel as if they will live forever. Of course we all know on some level that we won’t, but the young find this easy to ignore. Feeling like you will live...

The Future of Data Centers

The Future of Data Centers

My column in OnlySky In 2017, Norfolk Southern Railroad received a $20 million state grant to modify bridges and tracks on Pittsburgh's North Side to accommodate double-stack freight trains. This work included enlarging a railroad trench in a park near my house and...

Managed By Cassus Media